Ericaceae-Neotropical Blueberries
James L. Luteyn and Paola Pedraza
The New York Botanical
Garden
Introduction
General Circumscription, Distribution, and Classification
of Ericales. The Ericales is an order of about 4500 species of plants,
traditionally arranged in eight families with about 160 genera (Bentham &
Hooker, 1876; Drude, 1891; Stevens, 1971; Cronquist, 1981;
Dahlgren, 1983; Thorne, 1992). The eight "traditional" families
include: Cyrillaceae, Clethraceae, Grubbiaceae, Empetraceae, Epacridaceae,
Pyrolaceae, Monotropaceae, and Ericaceae. About 90% of the species belong
to the Ericaceae (in the traditional sense) and most of the remainder to the
Epacridaceae. The other six families have only a little more than a
hundred species in all.
The Cyrillaceae (or Cyrilla Family) consists of 3
genera and l4 species, occurring in northern South America, Central America,
the West Indies, and on the coastal plain of southeastern United States.
The Clethraceae (or Clethra Family) consists of 1 genus (Clethra) with
about 65 species, occurring from tropical South America north to Mexico and
southeastern United States, and also in tropical and subtropical southeastern
Asia and the East Indies. The Grubbiaceae (or Grubbia Family) consists
of 1 genus (Grubbia) with 3 species, occurring only in the Cape region
of South Africa. The Empetraceae (or Crowberry Family) consists of 3
genera with about 5 species, occurring in the colder parts of the Northern
Hemisphere, southern South America, and the coastal plain of southeastern
United States. The Epacridaceae (or Epacris Family) consists of 30 genera
and 400 species, occuring primarily in Australia and New Zealand, but also
reaching north to the Philippine Islands and mainland Southeastern Asia, and
extending east to the Hawaiian Islands and Patagonia. The Pyrolaceae
(or Shinleaf Family) consists of 4 genera and about 45 species, occurring
only in the Northern Hemisphere, and being most diverse in north temperate
and boreal regions. The Monotropaceae (or Indian Pipe Family) consists
of 10 genera and 12 species, occurring mostly in temperate and boreal regions
of the Northern Hemisphere, but one New World species ranges south nearly
approaching the Equator in Colombia, and another Old World species nears the
same latitude in the Malay Peninsula. This family lacks chlorophyll
(the green, food producing plant pigment) and is best known for the Indian
Pipe genus (Monotropa). The Ericaceae (or Heath Family), consisting
of about 110 genera and 4000 species, is a diverse and geographically widespread
family, occurring in temperate and cool tropical regions of all continents
except Antarctica, and with greatest diversity in the montane Neotropics.
On a worldwide basis, many of the subgroupings within the family Ericaceae
have radiated in distinct continental areas. For example, the blueberry
subfamily (Vaccinioideae), with over 1000 species, is most abundant in the
tropics of the New World, Malaysia, and southeastern Asia. There they
usually occur as epiphytic shrubs in the cool, moist montane regions referred
to as cloud forests, although a few species range into typically tropical
situations. The largest blueberry genus is Vaccinium with some
450 species, scattered throughout the world, but especially in southeast Asia
and Malesia. The heath subfamily (Ericoideae) is confined to Africa
and Europe, with a proliferation of over 650 species of Erica in the
Cape region of southern Africa. The rhododendron subfamily (Rhododendroideae)
consists primarily of the ornamental genus Rhododendron (including
the azaleas), which contains 800-900 species in the mountains of Himalaya
and western China, and on the island of New Guinea. For more information
about infrafamilial relationships within the Ericaceae, see Stevens (1995).
In addition to the eight ericalean families, two
others (Actinidiaceae and Diapensiaceae) are sometimes included within the
Ericales by taxonomists. If referred to the Ericales, the family Actinidiaceae
(including the Saurauiaceae) would be the most archaic family, although anomalous
with regards to several morphological features that could be easily accommodated
in the order Theales. The Diapensiaceae, although related to the Ericales,
are removed from them because of a long list of differences, including embryological,
staminal, and palynological features. They too are probably better associated
with the Theales.
Current Overall Classification. The
classification systems of Ericalean families mentioned above have undergone
many changes. For example, the close relationships among the families
Clethraceae, Ericaceae, and Epacridaceae have been evident for many years,
with these three core families comprising more than 99% of the species of
the order. In recent years, however, there has been almost universal
acceptance of the inclusion of Empetraceae and Cyrillaceae in the order, based
especially on similarities in embryological and palynological features with
those of the Ericaceae. The Cyrillaceae was previously assigned to the
Celastrales (and associated with the family Celastraceae). The move
to the Ericales has been generally accepted based on the accumulation of embryological
and palynological studies. Inclusion of the family Grubbiaceae has been
fairly recent and there is still some question as to the exact relationship.
This family has often been placed in the order Santalales because of the structure
of its pistil. The ovary is inferior and as it begins its development,
it is more or less two-locular. As the ovary continues to mature it
becomes unilocular with a standing, free-central placenta that bears two pendulous
ovules. This ovular structure is typically santalalean and completely
atypical of the order Ericales. There are, however, other features which
cause it to be misplaced in the Santalales including anatomical differences,
its autotrophic not parasitic habit, and no close relationships to any other
family in the Santalales. On the other hand, Grubbiaceae is distinctly
ericoid in habit, embryological and palynological features, and in the similarly
inverted position of the anthers during development. Furthermore, the
Monotropaceae and Pyrolaceae are often treated as Monotropoideae and Pyroloideae,
respectively, or sometimes Monotropaceae is combined with Pyrolaceae.
The Pyrolaceae and Monotropaceae have the reduced embryo that so often accompanies
parasitism or extreme mycotrophy in other groups and these relationships probably
represent progressive stages in dependence on a mycorhizal fungus (Cronquist,
1981).
Most recently, several studies, using cladistic techniques
combined with new data from molecular and morphological systematics, have
brought to light the need for major realignments at familial, subfamilial,
tribal, and generic levels within Ericaceae (Anderberg, 1992, 1993;
Chase et al., 1993; Judd and Kron, 1993; Kron and Chase, 1993;
Kron, 1996, 1997; Powell et al., 1996), and a new, higher-level classification
of Ericaceae is currently being developed (Kron et al., in preparation).
These recent analyses have resulted in the conclusion that Ericaceae, as currently
recognized, are paraphyletic and that Empetraceae, Epacridaceae, Monotropaceae,
and Pyrolaceae are derivative lineages out of Ericaceae. The exact relationships
of Cyrillaceae, Clethraceae, and Actinidiaceae to Ericaceae are not certain
at this time.
Natural History of Neotropical Ericaceae.
In the Neotropics, the Ericaceae is concentrated in northwestern South America,
in the cooler, moist, montane forest habitats between 1500 to 3000 m elevation,
in primarily Colombia, Ecuador, Peru, and Venezuela, where nearly 50% of the
species are epiphytes and approximately 94% are endemic (Luteyn, 1989).
There are 46 genera and about 900 species, with the largest genera including
Cavendishia (150), Thibaudia (60), Psammisia (60), Vaccinium
(ca. 48), Macleania (40), Disterigma (ca. 40), Gaylussacia
(40), Gaultheria (37), and Ceratostema (34). As a general
rule, Ericaceae prefers partially exposed, moist, cool habitats and acid soils,
and is closely associated with endotropic mycorrhiza. Ericads
are often a prominent feature, dominating a major vegetation type of tropical
montane regions known as the "ericaceous belt," and because of their sun-loving
ecology, they are frequently found as pioneers near the craters of volcanoes
or in recent landslide areas. Pernettya prostrata forms carpets
or creeping mats over many acres in the mountains of Mexico and Guatemala,
as well as in the superpáramo at Nevado del Cocuy, Colombia (Luteyn,
1995). In the high-elevation páramo, Pernettya resists
trampling by cattle and is a successional species where grazing pressures
increase. It is frequently a pioneer species in new habitats created
by road building, landslides, man-made fires, or volcanic activity.
It invades the páramo when the vegetation structure is low and open,
but may remain when vegetation recovers. Fire does not affect it directly,
but actually helps spread it indirectly because it opens the vegetation (Pels
& Verweij, 1992). In Colombia, several ericads are found as epiphytes
in the Pacific-coast mangroves. In Venezuelan Guayana, Notopora schomburgkiana
and Vaccinium spp. are typical elements in the sandy savanna shrubberies.
In the Neotropics in general, whenever the habitat becomes dry (for example,
on the lee side of a mountain), more seasonal, or overly warm (tropical rainforest),
Ericaceae disappears.
Pollination of Ericacae in temperate and subtropical
latitudes is primarily by bees, but in the Neotropics bird-pollination is
the rule with hummingbirds acting
as the main vector. The flowers of many tropical American blueberries
display a number of morphological features associated with pollination by
hummingbirds: the flowers are odorless (hummingbirds have no sense of
smell); flowers are relatively showy and their associated bracts often
have contrasting colors in some shade of red, violet, or orange (which attract
hummingbirds and are not particularly alluring to insects); the corollas
are regular and tubular in shape, with a constricted throat and spreading
lobes (to exclude large insects); the flowers are pendent or arching
in habit and are arranged in open, elongate or few-flowered clusters (suited
to hummingbirds which feed in flight); a nectar secreting disc is located
on top of the ovary at the base of the corolla (so the visitor needs a proboscis);
corolla tubes are thick and fleshy (to protect them from damage by a probing
bill); corollas correspond well to the size and proportions of the bills
of visiting hummingbirds; and sugar concentrations in the nectar fall
into the range preferred by hummingbirds (total range 7-32%)(see Luteyn &
Sylva S., 1999). In connection with hummingbird pollination, nectar-thieving
mites (Rhinoseius spp.) spend virtually their entire life cycle within
the flowers of certain ericaceous hummingbird plants. The mites depend
not only upon the flowers as their source of nectar, but also upon the birds
themselves, as their primary means of dispersal is on the bill or in the nasal
cavities of hummingbirds. Dispersal of the small, light seeds
in genera such as Bejaria, Lyonia, and Agarista, which
have capsular fruits, is by wind; however, most of the neotropical genera
are berry-fruited and birds or small mammals probably act as agents of dispersal.
General Economic Uses of Ericaceae.
In temperate regions, the number of ericad species used as ornamentals is
inordinately large when compared with other plant groups of similar size.
Many of the most beautiful and prized horticultural plants throughout temperate
regions of the world are found in the Ericaceae, notable examples being azaleas,
rhododendrons, heaths, and heathers. Some of the most spectacular bursts
of color in the Spring are produced by these shrubs, and they are widely used
not only for the beauty of their blooms, but also for the value of the many
evergreen species as effective background shrubs. Natural species are
cultivated, and many hybrids have originated in cultivation (there are over
6000 cultivars of rhododendrons and azaleas). Economically, in temperate
regions, blueberries and cranberries are among the most important members
of the family, being in constant demand. Their commercial production
is worth in excess of hundreds of millions of dollars annually. The
cultivated "highbush" blueberry, developed primarily from Vaccinium corymbosum
and V. australe from eastern North America, has been domesticated entirely
in the twentieth century. Cranberries (Vaccinium macrocarpon)
are a native North American plant that have been cultivated in New England
since the early nineteenth century. The major toxic substance in Ericaceae
seems to be andromedotoxin. This compound is known to occur in temperate
species of Rhododendron, Leucothoe, Menziesia, Ledum,
and Kalmia, and is probably more widespread than is now known.
The leaves, twigs, flowers, and pollen grains of these genera all contain
andromedotoxin. The course of the poisoning includes watering of the
mouth, eyes and nose, loss of energy, vomiting, slow pulse, low blood pressure,
lack of coordination, convulsions, and slow and progressive paralysis of arms
and legs until death; fatalities, however, are rare. Humans can
be poisoned by chewing on leaves and twigs, brewing "tea" from the leaves,
or by sucking nectar from the flowers of these plants. Poisonous honey,
produced by bees after visiting large stands of Rhododendron, has been
known for over twenty-four hundred years. The honey is normally so bitter
to the taste, however, that very little of it can be eaten. Various
species of Rhododendron and laurel (Kalmia) have long been known
to be poisonous to domesticated animals (Luteyn, 1993).
In the Neotropics, there are very few published accounts
of uses of native Ericaceae. Rhododendron simsii, native to Asia,
is often cultivated terrestrially or in hanging baskets in the montane regions
of Central America and northwestern South America. Vaccinium floribundum
seems to be the most frequently used native species, especially in Ecuador
and Colombia, where the fruits are made into jams, drinks, and occasionally
pies. There are mixed reports, both in the literature and orally, as
to the edible nature of the fruits of Pernettya in their natural habitats.
These reports range from statements that the fruits are sweet or edible, although
somewhat insipid, to claims of intoxication (the Peruvian vernacular name
"macha-macha" means drunkenness; cf. Macbride, 1959 and Sleumer, 1985) or
hallucination after eating (see Luteyn, 1995). Sleumer (pers. comm.)
has eaten quantities of P. mucronata (in Argentina) and P. prostrata
(in Venezuela) without side effects. The nutritional and toxic aspects
of the fruits of P. prostrata were reported by Gutiérrez (1989).
The symptoms of intoxication included salivation, vomiting, colic pains, depression
of respiration, debility, collapse, and finally death.
Acknowledgments. Most of the information
in this neotropical Ericaceae web site has been taken from and reflects both
the published and unpublished research of James L. Luteyn gathered throughout the course of his career
at The New York Botanical Garden since 1975. Grants from the National Science Foundation (DEB-8004283, DEB-7713455, DEB-8300080, DEB-9628841,
BSR-8318375, BSR-8317561, BSR-9024221,
and BSR-9903719), Jessie
Smith Noyes Foundation, the Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, the National Geographic
Society, USAID, the USDA Agricultural Research Service, The Swedish Natural Science Research Council
and the University of Aarhus (Denmark) have helped
to sponsor the research. Olga Orozco helped with the initial data entry; Paola Pedraza is responsable for the current web site design. Any reuse of images or text from this website should be cleared with the authors.