Indian Reed
Canna indica

American Cowslip
Dodecatheon meadia

Round-Leaf Sundew
Drosera rotundifolia

Lamb of Tartary
Cibotium barometz

Sensitive Plant
Mimosa pudica

Peruvian Bark Tree
Cinchona officinalis

Golden Shower Tree
Cassia fistula

Night-Blowing Cereus
Selenicereus grandiflorus

Pheasant’s-Eye
Adonis annua

Indian Reed
Canna indica

American Cowslip
Dodecatheon meadia

Round-Leaf Sundew
Drosera rotundifolia

Lamb of Tartary
Cibotium barometz

Sensitive Plant
Mimosa pudica

Peruvian Bark Tree
Cinchona officinalis

Golden Shower Tree
Cassia fistula

Night-Blowing Cereus
Selenicereus grandiflorus

Pheasant’s-Eye
Adonis annua

  • Start
  • About
  • Contact
  • Contributors
  • Survey
  • Share
  • The New York Botanical Garden
  • The LuEsther Mertz Library
  • The Humanities Institute
  • The Steere Virtual Herbarium

Night-Blowing Cactus Selenicereus grandiflorus

Night-Blowing Cactus Selenicereus grandiflorus

Night-Blowing Cactus
Selenicereus grandiflorus

Illustration of Catus in Candolle Illustration of Catus in Candolle

A. P. Candolle

Plantes Grasses  (1799—1837)

A. P. Candolle
Plantes Grasses

(1799—1837)

“Cactus grandiflorus, repens subquinquangularis. Lin. Spec. 668.

“Cactier a grandes fleurs. Lam. Dict. n. 20.

“Cactus scandens angulis quinque pluribusque obtusis. Lin. Hort. Cliff. 182. n. 10. descr. excl. syn. Herm. Boerh. et Pluk.

“Cereus scandens angulis quinque obtusis. Lin. Hort. Ups. 121. n. 11. Roy. Lugd-b. 280.

“Cereus scandens minor polygonus articulatus. Mill. Icon. t. 90.

“Cereus gracilis scandens ramosus plerumque sexangularis flore ingenti atque fragranti. Trew. Ehret. t. 51. 52. E. N. C. 1752. v. 9. app. 184. t. 11. 12. 13.”

Illustration of Catus in Thornton Illustration of Catus in Thornton

Robert Thornton

Temple of Nature  (1807)

Robert Thornton
Temple of Nature

(1807)

“It has the appellation also of Night-blowing Cereus, from its opening its beautiful flowers after sun-set. Others have styled it the Torch Thistle, from the armature about its pentangular, articulated, and climbing stem, which is leafless, succulent, and exhibits to the observer a figure equally grotesque as terrific, with flowers possessing actually the blazing appearance of a torch. I have sometimes seen in our hot-houses twenty or thirty of these flowers expanded in the same evening, emitting all the while a fine balsamic odor.”

Illustration of Cactus in Andrews Illustration of Cactus in Andrews

Henry C. Andrews

The Botanist’s Repository  (1807—8)

Henry C. Andrews
The Botanist’s Repository

(1807—8)

“This elegant hot-house plant has been figures by several authors, and is well known by the appellation of the Night-blowing Cereus, and yet but few of Flora’s lovely train, warmed by the mid-day sun’s refulgent beams, in splendor can compare with this nocturnal beauty, whose brilliant flowers expand about sun-set. But, alas! too soon condemned to fate, they close up early on the following morn. Sometimes they have been found unclosed almost within an hour of noon: a circumstance that very rarely happens, as it generally displays its graceful blossoms to Cynthia’s silver beams, perfuming the still cool air of midnight with its aromatic fragrance.”

Illustration of Cactus in Descourtilz Illustration of Cactus in Descourtilz

M. E. Descourtilz

Flore Médicale des Antilles  (1821)

M. E. Descourtilz
Flore Médicale des Antilles

(1821)

“Chemical Analysis. This cactus, and its congeners, provides a milky juice, gum resin, dried and concentrated by the action of the air and heat. This concentrated juice is odorless, but subject to cheewing, it becomes progressively acrid, burning, and nauseous. It contains an extractive material, aluminum, and a principle very volatile and painfully effusive to smell. The causticity resides in the resinous part, which is combined in the the milky juice with equal parts of gum, which makes its alcoholic tincture endowed with all the heroic virtues.”

 Illustration of Cactus in Botanical Cabinet  Illustration of Cactus in Botanical Cabinet

Conrad Loddiges & Sons

The Botanical Cabinet  (1830)

Conrad Loddiges & Sons
The Botanical Cabinet

(1830)

“A native of the West Indies: from its very great beauty, and the facility of binging it home, it was early introduced into this country, and certainly ought to have a corner in every hothouse.

“In its native places its rooting branches attach themselves to the bark of trees, and climb to their tops.

“Our figure is reduced to two-thirds of its natural size. The flower opens in the evening, and remains till morning, during which time the whole stove is perfumed with its delicate fragrance: by eight or nine o’clock it closes, and opens no more.”

Cactus illustration in Curtis' Botanical Magazine Cactus illustration in Curtis' Botanical Magazine

Samuel Curtis & W. J. Hooker

Curtis’s Botanical Magazine  (1835)

Samuel Curtis & W. J. Hooker
Curtis’s Botanical Magazine

(1835)

“While the Cereus speciosissimus, as its name would lead us to expect, produces flowers of a remarkably large size, and possessing very brilliant colors, the subject of our present figure yields to no plant in the size, delicacy, and fragrance of its blossoms: nor are these its only peculiarities.”

Cactus herbarium specimen Cactus herbarium specimen

J. A. Shafer

NYBG Steere Herbarium Specimen (1912)

J. A. Shafer
NYBG Steere Herbarium

(1912)

Herbarium Specimen

Location: Cuba. Vicinity of Sumidero.

Collector: J. A. Shafer (28 Jul 1912—31 Jul 1912)

Description: Phenology of specimen: Fruit.

Note: Examined for The Cactaceae, Carnegie Institution of Washington.

Drosera rotundifolia herbarium specimen Drosera rotundifolia herbarium specimen

William Shewbridge

Night Blooming Cereus (2008)

William Shewbridge
Night Blooming Cereus

(2008)

Location: Rurrenbaque, Bolivia.

Date: 25 September 2008.

Camera: Canon EOS 50D.

Aperture: ƒ/4.5.

Shutter: 1/160.

Focal Length: 60mm.

ISO: 3200.

Previous Next
Erasmus Darwin’s The Botanic Garden  (1791)

Nymph! not for thee the radiant day returns,
Nymph! not for thee the golden solstice burns,
Refulgent Cerea!—at the dusky hour15
She seeks with pensive step the mountain-bower,
Bright as the blush of rising morn, and warms
The dull cold eye of Midnight with her charms.
There to the skies she lifts her pencill'd brows,
Opes her fair lips, and breathes her virgin vows;20
Eyes the white zenith; counts the suns, that roll
Their distant fires, and blaze around the Pole;
Or marks where Jove directs his glittering car
O’er Heaven’s blue vault,—Herself a brighter star.
—There as soft zephyrs sweep with pausing airs25
Thy snowy neck, and part thy shadowy hairs,
Sweet Maid of Night! to Cynthia’s sober beams
Glows thy warm cheek, polish’d bosom gleams.
In crowds around thee gaze the admiring swains,
And guard in silence the enchanted plains;30
Drop the still tear, or breathe the impassion’d sigh
And drink the inebriate rapture from thine eye.

Cerea. l. 15. Cactus grandiflorus, or Cereus. Twenty males, one female. This flower is a native of Jamaica and Veracrux. It expands a most exquisitely beautiful corol, and emits a most fragrant odor for a few hours in the night, and then closes to open no more. The flower is nearly a foot in diameter; the inside of the calyx of a splendid yellow, and the numerous petals of a pure white: it begins to open about seven or eight o’clock in the evening, and closes before sun-rise in the morning....

The Nyctanthes, called Arabian Jasmine, is another flower, which expands a beautiful corol, and gives out a most delicate perfume during the night, and not in the day, in its native country, whence its name; botanical philosophers have not yet explained this wonderful property; perhaps the plant sleeps during the day as some animals do; and its odoriferous glands only omit their fragrance during the expansion of the petals; that is, during its waking hours: the Geranium triste has the same property of giving up its fragrance only in the night. The flowers of the Cucurbita lagenaria are said to close when the sun shines upon them. In our climate many flowers, as tragopogon, and hibiscus, close their flowers before the hottest part of the day comes on; and the flowers of some species of cucubalus, and Silene, viscous campion, are closed all day; but when the sun leaves them they expand, and emit a very agreeable scent; whence such plants are termed noctiflora.

(II.4:13—32)

Taxonomy

Linnæan Classification

Class: 12. Icosandria (Twenty Males)
Order: 1. Monogynia (One Female)
Genus: Cactus
Species: Cactus grandiflorus

Modern Classification

Class: Equisetopsida C. Agardh
Sub-
class:
Magnoliidae Novák ex Takht.
Super-
order
Caryophyllanae Takht.
Order: Caryophyllales Juss.
ex Bercht. & J. Presl
Family: Cactaceae Juss.
Genus: Selenicereus (A. Berger)
Britton & Rose
Species: Selenicereus grandiflorus
(L.) Britton & Rose
Plants That Are Night Owls

The Night-Blowing (Blooming) Cereus, which Linnæus dubbed Cactus grandiflorus, now called Selenicereus grandiflorus, begins the fourth and final canto of Darwin’s poem, The Botanic Garden (1791). It provides a fitting transition from the previous third canto, which depicted sorrow and fear through plants that are spooky, stinging, parasitic, and intoxicating. (Darwin, perhaps embarrassed after a drunken naked rant, strongly advocated abstinence from alcohol, consequently chiding the vintner for “converting perfectly good food into poison”).

He also describes plants that are perfectly poisonous on their own, without any need of the vintner’s intervention. One plant he mentions is the Upas Poison-Tree from Java. His depiction of it is so jarring that it inspired the British painter Francis Danby to compose a work based on it. Darwin’s incredible description is contained in the footnote to this plant’s verse. He recounts that criminals on the island of Java are sent to the tree to retrieve its juice, which was used to make poison arrows. If they returned, they were pardoned. But only 1 in 4 returned. Darwin continues, “Not only animals of all kinds, both quadrupeds, fish, and birds, but all kinds of vegetables also are destroyed by the effluvia of the noxious tree; so that, in a district of 12 to 14 miles round it, the face of the earth is quite barren and rocky, intermixed only with the skeletons of men and animals; affording a sense of melancholy beyond what poets have described or painters delineated” (p. 110n). Perhaps accepting the challenge posed in Darwin’s final line, Danby depicts this very scene—a barren, uncanny land, in which two criminals approach the tree. Seemingly, only one will escape its noxious effluvia.

Darwin’s third terrifying canto begins with Circaea or Enchanter’s Nightshade, a plant used, as its name implies, in witchcraft, and often found growing on the “mouldering bones” beneath fresh graves. Whereas this plant’s macabre habitat brings the reader into the darkness of night, the Night-Blowing Cereus provides a light to lead her out of it, for this plant has the peculiar quality of blooming at night—and only at night.

Since the previous day, the flower has laid in preparation. Then, it begins opening on a July evening, around 7 or 8 o’clock, and reaches its peak bloom at midnight. Hence, in Robert John Thornton’s illustration of the cactus (pictured above), the artist has included a clock in the background whose hands read just past midnight. Thornton commissioned additional versions of this illustration. For example, in another edition (also pictured on this page), although still striking, much of what made the above one so remarkable is omitted. The moon no longer peeks out from behind the branches, the building no longer bears the large gilded clock showing the time, and a menacing creature no longer perches near the turret. A still additional version of the illustration serves as the frontispiece to Thornton’s Juvenile Botany, in which a father and son discuss botany (1818).

The Cactus grandiflorus is worthy of attention for the fact that it blossoms at night. These blooms are also notable because, as the name implies, they are quite large, nearly a foot in diameter. In the eighteenth century, this species was thought to possess the largest flower of all the cacti, hence receiving the name, grandiflorus or “large flower.” However, it is now recognized that the blossom size of the species is relatively modest. Nevertheless, the beauty of this flower is not diminished in the least. Quite the contrary, for once it does bloom, the cactus emits a fragrance that perfumes the air with a heady fragrance, redolent of vanilla.

Darwin notes that botanists have not yet explained why the cactus blooms at night, yet he proposes that the plant, just like some animals, could be nocturnal, resting during the day and thus avoiding the heat of the sun. The famous German naturalist, Johann Friedrich Blumenbach, draws the same analogy, arguing that plants like the Night-Blowing Cereus sleep during the day in order to recover their energy, just as some animals. For Darwin and Blumenbach as well as many other eighteenth-century botanists, this hypothesis follows from a much more widely discussed and observed phenomenon: many plants sleep at night. Recently, European researchers confirmed this activity, or lack thereof, in trees. They employed laser scanners to measure the droop of branches and leaves at night: trees of around 5 meters in height drooped around 10 cm at night and then returned to their original position in the morning. Research on the mechanisms responsible for this day-night rhythm, which likely include changes in turgor caused by the presence and absence of light, are ongoing. For more on how Darwin and others understood the sleep of plants, see the exhibition note for Mimosa pudica.

Even if we granted Darwin and Blumenbach’s hypotheses, they do not explain too much, for we are left asking why some plants are nocturnal or “noctiflora,” while others are not. We are still left with the nagging question of why the Selenicereus grandiflorus blooms at night. The answer to this question is not one that would have been readily understood in Darwin’s time because botanists were only beginning to understand the specific relationships that exist between flowers and their pollinators. Yet, in his Juvenile Botany, Thornton hits on this very idea:

Son.—I have seen some butterflies, which like bats, only fly at night.

Father.—These are called Moths, whose bodies resemble butter more than the butterfly, and there are flowers, which open at night, to furnish them with food, as the Evening Primrose (Aenothera), and the Night-blowing Cereus (Cactus Grandiflora).

(p. 93)

Thornton was, in fact, precisely right, for it is now recognized that this cactus blooms at night because of its relationship with its pollinators, which must also be nocturnal, that is, bats and moths. In addition to its sweet scent, the opalescent white petals of the Night-Blooming Cereus reflect moonlight that directs these pollinators toward the flower. Whether these bats and moths are so smitten with these blooms that they hold viewing parties in their honor is still yet to be known.

Selenicereus grandiflorus (1920)
Illustration of Selenicereus grandiflorua

—from N. L. Britton and J. N. Rose’s The Cactaceae

Help us improve this exhibition

Take a Survey

An Excerpt From The Gentleman’s Magazine and Historical Chronicle  (Vol. 49, 1779)

To which we may add that exceeding beautiful flower of the Cactus grandiflorus, or Night-blowing-Cereus, which, as others of this genus, never opens before seven or eight in the evening, and decays before three or four o’clock next morning: this blows in the month of July; and I can assure the curious, that no plant I ever saw yet appears in this state more beautiful, the flower being near a foot in diameter, of a fine yellow, surrounded with white petals; to this may be added th agreeable odor of the same, which extends to a great distance, but only lasting during the expansion of the flower: indeed, on a vigorous plant, there may be a succession of flowers, night after night, but rarely lasting more than six or eight hours in bloom.

(p. 128)

Alternative Illustration of Night-blowing Cereus (1812)
Illustration of the Venus Flytrap

from John Thornton’s A Temple of Flora

J. J. Rousseau’s
Letters on the Elements of Botany: Addressed to a Lady  (3rd ed., 1791)

Some of the Cereuses are much esteemed for the beauty of their flowers, which are perhaps the more noticed, because they are the less expected from plants whose appearance is so unpromising. Those of the Great-Flowering Creeping CereusP are near a foot in diameter, the inside of the calyx of a splendid yellow, and the numerous petals of a pure white: hardly any flower makes so magnificent an appearance during the short time of its duration, which is one night only; for it does not begin to open till seven or eight o’clock in the evening, and closes before sun-rise in the morning, unless it is gathered and kept in the shade, by which means I have prevented it from closing till about ten. This noble flower opens but once; but when, to the grandeur of its appearance, we add the fine perfume which it diffuses, there is no plant that more deserves your admiration. When it is not in blow, you will know it by the creeping stem, marked longitudinally with about five prominences.

P Cactus grandiflorus Lin. Mill. fig. pl. 90.

(pp. 287—88)

Help us improve this exhibition

Take a Survey

Selenicereus grandiflorus (1754)
Illustration of Cactus grandiflorus by Ehret

from G. D. Ehret’s Plantae selectae

Plants That Are Night Owls

The Night-Blowing (Blooming) Cereus, which Linnæus dubbed Cactus grandiflorus, now called Selenicereus grandiflorus, begins the fourth and final canto of Darwin’s poem, The Botanic Garden (1791). It provides a fitting transition from the previous third canto, which depicted sorrow and fear through plants that are spooky, stinging, parasitic, and intoxicating. (Darwin, perhaps embarrassed after a drunken naked rant, strongly advocated abstinence from alcohol, consequently chiding the vintner for “converting perfectly good food into poison”).

He also describes plants that are perfectly poisonous on their own, without any need of the vintner’s intervention. One plant he mentions is the Upas Poison-Tree from Java. His depiction of it is so jarring that it inspired the British painter Francis Danby to compose a work based on it. Darwin’s incredible description is contained in the footnote to this plant’s verse. He recounts that criminals on the island of Java are sent to the tree to retrieve its juice, which was used to make poison arrows. If they returned, they were pardoned. But only 1 in 4 returned. Darwin continues, “Not only animals of all kinds, both quadrupeds, fish, and birds, but all kinds of vegetables also are destroyed by the effluvia of the noxious tree; so that, in a district of 12 to 14 miles round it, the face of the earth is quite barren and rocky, intermixed only with the skeletons of men and animals; affording a sense of melancholy beyond what poets have described or painters delineated” (p. 110n). Perhaps accepting the challenge posed in Darwin’s final line, Danby depicts this very scene—a barren, uncanny land, in which two criminals approach the tree. Seemingly, only one will escape its noxious effluvia.

Darwin’s third terrifying canto begins with Circaea or Enchanter’s Nightshade, a plant used, as its name implies, in witchcraft, and often found growing on the “mouldering bones” beneath fresh graves. Whereas this plant’s macabre habitat brings the reader into the darkness of night, the Night-Blowing Cereus provides a light to lead her out of it, for this plant has the peculiar quality of blooming at night—and only at night.

Since the previous day, the flower has laid in preparation. Then, it begins opening on a July evening, around 7 or 8 o’clock, and reaches its peak bloom at midnight. Hence, in Robert John Thornton’s illustration of the cactus (pictured above), the artist has included a clock in the background whose hands read just past midnight. Thornton commissioned additional versions of this illustration. For example, in another edition (also pictured on this page), although still striking, much of what made the above one so remarkable is omitted. The moon no longer peeks out from behind the branches, the building no longer bears the large gilded clock showing the time, and a menacing creature no longer perches near the turret. A still additional version of the illustration serves as the frontispiece to Thornton’s Juvenile Botany, in which a father and son discuss botany (1818).

The Cactus grandiflorus is worthy of attention for the fact that it blossoms at night. These blooms are also notable because, as the name implies, they are quite large, nearly a foot in diameter. In the eighteenth century, this species was thought to possess the largest flower of all the cacti, hence receiving the name, grandiflorus or “large flower.” However, it is now recognized that the blossom size of the species is relatively modest. Nevertheless, the beauty of this flower is not diminished in the least. Quite the contrary, for once it does bloom, the cactus emits a fragrance that perfumes the air with a heady fragrance, redolent of vanilla.

Darwin notes that botanists have not yet explained why the cactus blooms at night, yet he proposes that the plant, just like some animals, could be nocturnal, resting during the day and thus avoiding the heat of the sun. The famous German naturalist, Johann Friedrich Blumenbach, draws the same analogy, arguing that plants like the Night-Blowing Cereus sleep during the day in order to recover their energy, just as some animals. For Darwin and Blumenbach as well as many other eighteenth-century botanists, this hypothesis follows from a much more widely discussed and observed phenomenon: many plants sleep at night. Recently, European researchers confirmed this activity, or lack thereof, in trees. They employed laser scanners to measure the droop of branches and leaves at night: trees of around 5 meters in height drooped around 10 cm at night and then returned to their original position in the morning. Research on the mechanisms responsible for this day-night rhythm, which likely include changes in turgor caused by the presence and absence of light, are ongoing. For more on how Darwin and others understood the sleep of plants, see the exhibition note for Mimosa pudica.

Even if we granted Darwin and Blumenbach’s hypotheses, they do not explain too much, for we are left asking why some plants are nocturnal or “noctiflora,” while others are not. We are still left with the nagging question of why the Selenicereus grandiflorus blooms at night. The answer to this question is not one that would have been readily understood in Darwin’s time because botanists were only beginning to understand the specific relationships that exist between flowers and their pollinators. Yet, in his Juvenile Botany, Thornton hits on this very idea:

Son.—I have seen some butterflies, which like bats, only fly at night.

Father.—These are called Moths, whose bodies resemble butter more than the butterfly, and there are flowers, which open at night, to furnish them with food, as the Evening Primrose (Aenothera), and the Night-blowing Cereus (Cactus Grandiflora).

(p. 93)

Thornton was, in fact, precisely right, for it is now recognized that this cactus blooms at night because of its relationship with its pollinators, which must also be nocturnal, that is, bats and moths. In addition to its sweet scent, the opalescent white petals of the Night-Blooming Cereus reflect moonlight that directs these pollinators toward the flower. Whether these bats and moths are so smitten with these blooms that they hold viewing parties in their honor is still yet to be known.

The Upas, or Poison-Tree, in the Island of Java (ca. 1820)
The Upas, or Poison-Tree by Francis Danby

—by Francis Danby
©Victoria and Albert Museum, London

Taxonomy

Linnæan Classification

Class: 12. Icosandria (Twenty Males)
Order: 1. Monogynia (One Female)
Genus: Cactus
Species: Cactus grandiflorus

Modern Classification

Class: Equisetopsida C. Agardh
Sub-
class:
Magnoliidae Novák ex Takht.
Super-
order
Caryophyllanae Takht.
Order: Caryophyllales Juss.
ex Bercht. & J. Presl
Family: Cactaceae Juss.
Genus: Selenicereus (A. Berger)
Britton & Rose
Species: Selenicereus grandiflorus
(L.) Britton & Rose
Johann Friedrich Blumenbach’s Handbuch der Naturgeschichte  (6th ed., 1799)

In many plants, it is striking that both their leaves and in some their flowers fold up or drop down in the evening and take to something like a rest and fall asleep. This is not only caused by, for instance, the cool evening air, since it occurs in the hothouse just as in the open air: not even merely by darkness, since some plants fall sleep already in the midday in summer. In fact, just like the animalia nocturna who spend the day asleep, thus this is also the case with the flowers of a few plants, e.g., the cactus grandiflorus.... But this seems to be a requirement of periodic recovery, just like the sleep of animals.

(p. 483)

Selenicereus grandiflorus (1713)
Illustration of Selenicereus grandiflorus by Volckamer

—from J. C. Volkamer’sHesperidum Norimbergensium

Correspondence from The Monthly Review; or, Literary Journal  (Vol. 72, 1785)

Had our correspondent been acquainted with the Linnæan system, he would have spared himself the trouble of the preceding remark.—The plant, called by Florists the Night-blowing Cereus, is the very plant to which we alluded, the Cactus grandiflorus of Linnæus —the Cereus scandens minor polygonas articulatus of Miller’s Dictionary; or, which may be more satisfactory to our Correspondent, the Cereus Americanus major articulatus, flore maximo, nocte se aperiente, & suavissimum odorem spirante, of Volkamerus. As to the notion of its blowing only ‘one night in the whole year,’ it is as ill-founded, as were the superstitions about the blowing of the Glastonbury thorn on Christmas eve. It is true, that no one flower survives the night which gave it birth, neither can any human art preserve it beyond the destined hour of its fall: but then there is a succession of these flowers, some blowing on one night, and some on another. It blows only at night, the flower is usually in perfection at midnight, and dies away as the light of the morning approaches.

(p. 582)

Selenicereus grandiflorus (1754)
Illustration of Cactus grandiflorus by Ehret

from G. D. Ehret’s Plantae selectae

Quoted in William Jackson Hooker’s description in
Curtis’s Botanical Magazine  (1835)

‘Queen of the dark, whose tender glories fade
In the gay radiance of the noon-tide hours.’

‘That flower, supreme in loveliness, and pure
As the pale Cynthia’s beams, through which unveiled
It blooms, as if unwilling to endure
The gaze, by which such beauties are assailed.’

(vol. IX, 3381)

Continue the Exhibition

Next Species:

Pheasant’s-Eye (Adonis annua)

See it in the LuEsther Mertz Library
  • J. C. Volkamer, Hesperidum Norimbergensium (1713)
  • C. Linnæus, Species plantarum (1753)
  • C. Trew, Plantae selectae (1773)
  • E. Darwin, The Botanic Garden (1791)
  • J. J. Rousseau, Letters on the Elements of Botany (1791)
  • A. P. Candolle, Plantes Grasses (1804)
  • R. J. Thornton, Temple of Flora (1807)
  • H. C. Andrews, The Botanist&8217;s Repository (1814)
  • J. F. Blumenbach, A Manual of the Elements of Natural History (1825)
  • M. E. Descourtilz, Flore Médicale des Antilles (1829)
  • C. Loddiges & Sons, The Botanical Cabinet (1833)
  • W. J. Hooker, Curtis’s Botanical Magazine (1844)
  • N. L. Britton and J. N. Rose, The Cactaceae (1923)